How to Prove Fault in a Personal Injury Case
Proving fault in a personal injury case isn’t as simple or straightforward as you might think. It requires a clear understanding of some different core elements of what it means to be negligent. And in order to prove these elements, you’re going to need some legal assistance.
Table of Contents
Determining Legal Liability in an Injury Case
If there’s an accident involving an injury – such as a car accident, a slip and fall in an office building, or a safety incident in a store – it’s almost always either the result of an intentional and malicious act or unintentional negligence. And while the law certainly looks harshly upon intentional/malicious acts – i.e. crimes – there’s also accountability in place for negligent acts.
“If another party was responsible for the event that resulted in you getting hurt, you have the right to demand compensation for your losses,” attorney Mickey Keenan points out. “Even so, the law says that you must prove fault for the incident and demonstrate how your losses connect to that event.”
The basic rule of thumb is that if one person or entity who was involved in the accident was less careful than the other one – or less careful than they should have been – they must pay for at least a portion of the damages suffered by the other one who was more careful.
If that all sounds a bit vague, that’s because it kind of is. So, in order to create some clarity around the idea of liability, the legal system has created a litmus test of sorts. It consists of four specific elements that determine negligence and carelessness.
The 4 Fundamental Elements of Negligence
If you want to understand how to correctly and ethically point the finger at someone for an accident, you must get familiar with the four elements of negligence and be able to prove them.
Let’s explore in a bit more detail:
1. Duty of Care
By definition, a party can’t be responsible for your injuries or outcomes if there was no “duty of care” owed to you. In the legal world, duty of care basically means someone has a legal obligation to act reasonably and prevent harm to you.
Take car accidents as an example. In a car accident situation, drivers on the road have a duty to follow traffic laws and avoid stupid, reckless behavior. There’s an understanding that every driver is required to follow these rules.
2. Breach of Duty
To prove fault, you have to establish that a responsible party actually breached their duty of care. In other words, they didn’t live up to the expected standard that was in place. Using our previous example, if a driver runs through a red light, they’ve breached their duty of care by failing to obey traffic laws.
The third element is causation. This is a crucial element that must be proved. Just because someone ran a red light, doesn’t necessarily mean they’re legally negligent. You must be able to show that the breach of duty directly caused the injuries. This is where expert testimonies, evidence, and medical records often come into play in a personal injury case.
Proving fault also requires demonstrating the damages or losses incurred as a result of the accident. These damages can include medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, or property damage.
Keeping detailed records of medical bills, receipts, and any other related expenses will strengthen your case. For example, if you suffered a broken arm in the accident and had to undergo surgery, providing medical bills and doctor’s reports serves as evidence of your damages.
Adding it All Up
In order to prove fault in an injury case, all four of these elements must be proven. If a case only has two or three elements, it’s very unlikely that the outcome will be favorable.
If you’ve been hurt or injured in an accident – whether physically or psychologically – it’s important that you understand the four elements we’ve highlighted above. But don’t attempt to handle this on your own. You’re likely up against insurance companies with deep pockets and skilled negotiators. Hiring a lawyer on your side will help to level the playing field and put you in a position of greater power. Do this sooner rather than later!